Alderman Gardiner: ‘hypocrisy’ exists in City Council regarding who’s forgiven and who’s not for their mistakes 

by BRIAN NADIG

Alderman James Gardiner (45th) said he voted against the appointment of a county commissioner to the City Council at a special meeting on April 7 not because of his qualifications but because of the “hypocrisy” in how some alderpersons are treated.

Anthony Quezada has been tapped by Mayor Brandon Johnson to replace 35th Ward Alderman Carlos Ramirez-Rosa. Quezada has apologized for using the N-word in an exchange with friends in a social media post more than 10 years ago, with one alderman calling it a teachable moment. The 29-year-old Cook County commissioner was approved by a vote of 32-11 to replace Ramirez-Rosa, who resigned as the alderperson to become the chief executive officer of the Chicago Park District.

Several years ago Gardiner publicly apologized to the council for using misogynist language in text messages, but several council members refused to accept his apology. Some members even introduced legislation, which was never acted upon, to have him censured. Gardiner also has faced ethics board investigations, and several lawsuits, including one for removing critics from his aldermanic Facebook page. Gardiner is appealing a $20,000 fine which the ethics board imposed on him for allegedly having a fine wrongly issued against a constituent.

“The last 5 years have been challenging for me and my family. I’ve had a lot of allegations thrown at me … many false,” Gardiner said at the council’s meeting. “I’ve had protests outside of my office calling me every name, racist, homophobic, transphobic, every phobic you can imagine.”

He added that there were Black Lives Matter protests in front of his office and that a day later some of the same protesters were calling his wife’s employer to get his wife, who “just so happens to be an African-American,” fired, but none of that mattered because “we still wanted to go with the narrative that he’s somehow racist.”

Gardiner also said, “I wonder if I had made the same mistake (as Quezada), would this room be as forgiving?” Gardiner said. “I wonder if somebody who looked like me and had moderate political views like me … if this room would embrace me like you are embracing Anthony Quezada right now?”

He added, “I’m not voting against your appointment because of you. I’m voting against the hypocrisy in this room. Until we can start treating people equally and be just as forgiving to others who make mistakes, I’m a ‘No.’ I’m voting against it and I’m calling it out. … I think we’ve all made mistakes.”

After the meeting, Gardiner said, “A lot of people thanked me, (including) many people from the Brown and Black caucuses.”

He added, “We pick and choose who we forgive and who we don’t,” and as for Quezada, Gardiner said that the new alderperson made a mistake a long time ago and that he takes Quezada “at his word” when he said he’s sorry and wishes him success in his new role.

Ramirez-Rosa was also not immune to controversy. In 2023 he was accused of blocking Alderwoman Emma Mitts from entering the Council chambers regarding the city’s sanctuary city status and tried to get several other alderpersons from not attending the meeting. He later had to step down from his positions as Chicago City Council floor leader and chairman of the Committee on Zoning, Landmarks, and Building Standards. Rosa apologized after the incident.

 

  • Milwaukee-Giddings demo could start this month, as 23 apartments, commercial space planned for site
    by BRIAN NADIG The construction of a retail-residential development with 23 apartments at 4745-57 N. Milwaukee Ave. is set to kick off by the end of next spring, as demolition of the three existing buildings on the site could start this month. The project would bring redevelopment to a block of Milwaukee Avenue in Jefferson
  • How to find a dentist you’ll actually stick with in Chicago
    Choosing the right dentist can make a big difference in your oral health and comfort. Many Chicago residents in South Side Chicago struggle to find a dentist they feel good about returning to for regular care. Understanding what to look for, starting with your needs and lifestyle, can help you form a dental relationship that
  • NW Side aldermanic races already heating up
    by CHRISTOPHER BRINCKERHOFF Northwest Side challengers and incumbents in aldermanic races in next year’s Feb. 23 municipal election hit the ground running just as the mid-terms wrapped up last week.  At a meeting of the Old Irving Park Association on Nov. 4, candidates in the 45th, 39th and 30th wards echoed their campaigns and voiced
  • Opinion: The company you keep is latest controversy in 45th Ward
    by BRIAN NADIG “Never dull in 45.” That’s how the topsy-turvy dynamics of the 45th Ward have been described by aldermen, committeemen and journalists in the past 25 years It seems anything can blow up, at any time, into a “controversy.” Sometimes it’s an ex-alderman parking his boat on a city street, sometimes a politico
  • Acura cars reported stolen in Jefferson Park, as thieves crash one of the vehicles into tree, fence
    by BRIAN NADIG At least two Acura vehicles were reported stolen over the weekend in Jefferson Park, with one of them crashing moments later near Milwaukee and Lawrence avenues and the other being picked up by a license plate reader camera on the West Side, according to Chicago police. A 2021 Acura RLX was reported
Digital Edition No Pop-Ups

Weekly Digital Edition

Read every story. Skip every pop-up.

Get the full weekly edition delivered to your inbox — no interruptions, no waiting. Just local news the way it was meant to be read.

Only $19.50/year — less than 38¢ a week Subscribe Now

This is just part of today’s coverage. Get the full story - every article, every ad, every page. Subscribe now.

The Latest From Our Community

NW Side aldermanic races already heating up

by CHRISTOPHER BRINCKERHOFF Northwest Side challengers and incumbents in aldermanic races in next year’s Feb. 23 municipal election hit the ground running just as the mid-terms wrapped up last week.  read story

 





Photo by SumUp No Pop-Ups

Weekly Digital Edition

Read every story.
Skip every pop-up.

No pop-up ads — ever. Just stories, the way they were meant to be read

Full weekly edition delivered to your inbox every week — no waiting, no missing issues

Support local journalism and help keep our community connected

Only $19.50/year

That's less than 38¢ a week

Purchase Digital Subscription

Paypal

$19.50

/year

You can submit your payment via Paypal with a Credit Card. You DO NOT NEED TO HAVE A PAYPAL ACCOUNT.. Just click the “Paypal Subscribe” button below to iniate your secure payment! You will be directed to a Secure Paypal page in which you can pay with a Paypal account if you have one, or you can select "Pay with Debit or Credit Cardt" option below and process your payment via credit card.

Venmo

$19.50

/year

You can submit payment of $19.50 for a 1 year subscription to Nadig Newspapers' Venmo account using this link. Please include the email address in the comment/note section that you would like the digital subscription sent to.